Fishers Island (NY) hotels and places to stay

Search among 45 available hotels and places to stay in Fishers Island from 50+ providers

Check-in
Select date
-
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Check-in
Select date
-
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
Filter & Sort
View map
Check-in
Select date
-
Check-out
Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
View map
1-45 out of 45
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
Crystal Cove By Cozykey Vacation Rentals Fishers Island
Hotel
Map
1044.1 mi from City Center
The hotel has an outdoor swimming pool and lies close to Disney's Blizzard Beach Water Park which is worth visiting.
Select
Places to stay near Fishers Island
8.4
Great46 reviews
Map
6.7 mi from Fishers Island6.7 mi from City Center
Offering whirlpool baths and an indoor pool together with an indoor swimming pool, the Mystic Marriott Hotel And Groton near a train station is set in the business district of Groton.
FromUS$ 229 /nightSelect
8.4
Great162 reviews
Map
7.1 mi from Fishers Island7.1 mi from City Center
Located in the historical district of Mystic, the Hilton offers 182 rooms along with heated swimming pool.
FromUS$ 239 /nightSelect
8.2
Great45 reviews
Map
14.9 mi from Fishers Island14.9 mi from City Center
With views of the patio, the Stardust North Stonington is situated around 10 minutes' drive from Pelloni Farm and offers various recreational opportunities and entertainment activities.
FromUS$ 101 /nightSelect
8.4
Great124 reviews
Map
7.0 mi from Fishers Island7.0 mi from City Center
Set a 6-minute walk from Olde Mistick Village, the perfect Hyatt Place boasts spacious rooms along with fitness classes and various recreational opportunities available onsite.
FromUS$ 138 /nightSelect
8.2
Great58 reviews
Map
9.5 mi from Fishers Island9.5 mi from City Center
Located within 2.1 miles of Flying Horse Carousel, the 3-star smoke free Pleasant View Inn features 65 rooms with views of the pool.
FromUS$ 200 /nightSelect
8.4
Great67 reviews
Map
5.8 mi from Fishers Island5.8 mi from City Center
An à la carte restaurant and 37 rooms are available during the stay at the 3-star Whaler'S Inn, boasting a location 400 feet from Historic Downtown Mystic.
FromUS$ 270 /nightSelect
8.2
Great140 reviews
Map
7.4 mi from Fishers Island7.4 mi from City Center
Situated merely 5 minutes' walk from Charles W. Morgan, the comfortable Hampton Inn & Suites in Mystic features fitness classes and entertainment activities.
FromUS$ 187 /nightSelect
8.0
Great121 reviews
Map
7.6 mi from Fishers Island7.6 mi from City Center
Set 25 minutes by foot from Groton Bank Historic District, the 3-star Ramada By Wyndham boasts fitness classes, spa therapy and entertainment activities available on site.
FromUS$ 51 /nightSelect
8.4
Great233 reviews
Map
7.1 mi from Fishers Island7.1 mi from City Center
While staying at the smoke-free Howard Johnson By Wyndham you are invited to discover Fields Of Fire Adventure Park, set approximately 1.9 miles away, or Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration, which is 0.8 miles away.
FromUS$ 80 /nightSelect
8.4
Great46 reviews
Map
7.4 mi from Fishers Island7.4 mi from City Center
Located within 650 feet of Charles W. Morgan in the shopping district of Mystic, the Residence Inn Mystic Groton Mystic features 128 rooms along with various recreational opportunities and entertainment activities.
FromUS$ 269 /nightSelect
8.4
Great588 reviews
Map
7.5 mi from Fishers Island7.5 mi from City Center
Located around 2 miles from Fields Of Fire Adventure Park, the Spark By Hilton Mystic Groton Mystic boasts an outdoor swimming pool.
FromUS$ 64 /nightSelect
8.4
Great173 reviews
Map
8.1 mi from Fishers Island8.1 mi from City Center
Approximately a 25-minute stroll from United States Coast Guard Academy, the 3-star smoke free Holiday Inn New London, An Ihg offers various recreational opportunities and entertainment activities plus an indoor swimming pool.
FromUS$ 234 /nightSelect
8.6
Great38 reviews
Map
9.8 mi from Fishers Island9.8 mi from City Center
Located 1.1 miles from Atlantic Beach Park, the Hotel Maria features a continental breakfast.
FromUS$ 420 /nightSelect
8.2
Great100 reviews
Map
7.0 mi from Fishers Island7.0 mi from City Center
At the 3-star family-friendly Hampton Inn Groton/Mystic Groton, guests can use fitness classes, various recreational opportunities and entertainment activities or spend the day lazing by a swimming pool.
FromUS$ 110 /nightSelect
8.4
Great40 reviews
Map
9.9 mi from Fishers Island9.9 mi from City Center
The 3-star Breezeway Resort is set a 10-minute walk from Misquamicut State Beach and offers guests a swimming pool onsite.
FromUS$ 349 /nightSelect
8.4
Great48 reviews
Map
7.6 mi from Fishers Island7.6 mi from City Center
Within a 10-minute drive of Nathan Hale Schoolhouse, the charming Inn & Suites features fitness classes, entertainment activities and barbeque grills.
FromUS$ 79 /nightSelect
8.2
Great76 reviews
Map
7.1 mi from Fishers Island7.1 mi from City Center
Set around a 5-minute walk from Olde Mistick Village and in the shopping district of Mystic, the Holiday Inn Express Mystic, An Ihg Mystic has 77 rooms.
FromUS$ 109 /nightSelect
7.6
Very good31 reviews
Map
7.4 mi from Fishers Island7.4 mi from City Center
Around 15 miles from Richard Douglass House, the welcoming 2-star Rodeway Inn Groton features entertainment activities and various recreational opportunities.
FromUS$ 58 /nightSelect
8.4
Great95 reviews
Map
8.1 mi from Fishers Island8.1 mi from City Center
Within 17 miles of USS Nautilus Memorial, the 3-star Baymont By Wyndham Groton/Mystic Groton offers a swimming pool along with a hot tub and an indoor pool on-site.
FromUS$ 67 /nightSelect
8.0
Great107 reviews
Map
7.8 mi from Fishers Island7.8 mi from City Center
While staying at the 2-star Super 8 By Wyndham you are invited to discover Groton Bank Historic District, set 10 minutes' drive away, or The Hempsted Houses, which is 10 minutes' drive away.
FromUS$ 47 /nightSelect
8.4
Great45 reviews
Map
7.7 mi from Fishers Island7.7 mi from City Center
Boasting its location within 1.4 miles of Fort Griswold Battlefield State Park, the sophisticated 3-star Hilton Garden Inn Mystic/Groton Groton features spacious rooms as well as a hot tub and an indoor pool onsite.
FromUS$ 116 /nightSelect
Inn
8.4
Great146 reviews
Map
5.5 mi from Fishers Island5.5 mi from City Center
Set 9 minutes by foot from Williams Beach Park, the Taber Inn offers 34 rooms and a swimming pool.
FromUS$ 149 /nightSelect
8.2
Great30 reviews
Map
10.4 mi from Fishers Island10.4 mi from City Center
Avery Farm Nature Preserve is 1.8 miles away and Clyde's Cider Mill opens sept. 1st can be reached within 10 minutes by car.
FromUS$ 200 /nightSelect
8.2
Great239 reviews
Map
7.5 mi from Fishers Island7.5 mi from City Center
Sitting within 0.8 miles of Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration and adjacent to a metro station, the 3-star pet-friendly Quality Inn offers fitness classes and entertainment activities.
FromUS$ 79 /nightSelect
8.2
Great76 reviews
Map
7.4 mi from Fishers Island7.4 mi from City Center
Conveniently situated around 2 miles from The Submarine Force Museum in a business district, the quality Motel 6-Groton, Ct - Casinos Nearby Groton features 95 rooms and a swimming pool.
FromUS$ 72 /nightSelect
8.0
Great186 reviews
Map
7.1 mi from Fishers Island7.1 mi from City Center
Coogan Farm is also set about 5 minutes' walk from the 2-star Rodeway Inn Mystic.
FromUS$ 60 /nightSelect
8.0
Great147 reviews
Map
7.7 mi from Fishers Island7.7 mi from City Center
Comprising 44 rooms, the 2-star Flagship Inn & Suites is set near the historic district of Groton around 2.3 miles from The Submarine Force Museum.
FromUS$ 45 /nightSelect
Bed & Breakfast
8.8
Great18 reviews
Map
10.5 mi from Fishers Island10.5 mi from City Center
Boasting entertainment activities and water sports facilities, the 4-star Margin Street Inn Westerly is around 4.2 miles from Statue of Ninigret in an entertainment neighbourhood.
FromUS$ 425 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good11 reviews
Map
8.7 mi from Fishers Island8.7 mi from City Center
The 3-star House Of 1833 Bed And Breakfast Mystic is set approximately 1.9 miles from Cornerstone Playhouse and 10 minutes' stroll from Clyde's Cider Mill opens sept. 1st.
FromUS$ 289 /nightSelect
8.2
Great129 reviews
Map
7.3 mi from Fishers Island7.3 mi from City Center
Featuring 150 spacious rooms and an indoor swimming pool, the River Hotel & Suites is located 0.5 miles from Palmer House.
FromUS$ 125 /nightSelect
8.4
Great120 reviews
Map
5.6 mi from Fishers Island5.6 mi from City Center
Situated a 14-minute stroll from Williams Beach Park, the unique Inn At Mystic offers the outdoor swimming pool near a train station.
FromUS$ 79 /nightSelect
7.6
Very good64 reviews
Map
7.6 mi from Fishers Island7.6 mi from City Center
The Copp Family Park is set about 1.3 miles from the 2-star Days Inn & Suites By Wyndham Groton Near The Casinos Groton.
FromUS$ 60 /nightSelect
8.2
Great37 reviews
Map
7.6 mi from Fishers Island7.6 mi from City Center
The Hempsted Houses is about 2.6 miles from the 2-star Windsor Motel and Fort Trumbull State Park and Museum is around 2.7 miles away.
FromUS$ 55 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good50 reviews
Map
7.6 mi from Fishers Island7.6 mi from City Center
The smoke-free Americas Best Value Inn - is set 4.1 miles from Mystic Seaport Museum and 10 minutes' drive from Stonington's Old Lighthouse Museum.
FromUS$ 62 /nightSelect
Bed & Breakfast
Map
7.4 mi from Fishers Island7.4 mi from City Center
Guests can have a buffet breakfast and enjoy visiting Stonington Vineyards, set 15 minutes' drive from the 3-star Whitehall Mansion Mystic.
FromUS$ 153 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good96 reviews
Map
7.6 mi from Fishers Island7.6 mi from City Center
Located near a train station and around 10 minutes' drive from Nathan Hale Schoolhouse, the 2-star Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Groton offers spa therapy and entertainment activities.
FromUS$ 51 /nightSelect
8.2
Great29 reviews
Map
9.9 mi from Fishers Island9.9 mi from City Center
The 2-star Point 1 Resort & Motel is set 3.4 miles from Manfredi Farms and about 0.8 miles from Water Wizz of Westerly RI.
FromUS$ 134 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good104 reviews
Map
6.1 mi from Fishers Island6.1 mi from City Center
Eastern Point Beach is set 10 minutes' drive from the 2-star Hilltop Express Groton.
FromUS$ 120 /nightSelect
8.4
Great1 review
Map
9.9 mi from Fishers Island9.9 mi from City Center
Winnapaug Golf Course and Capizzano Olive Oils & Vinegars are located 1.6 miles and 4.2 miles from the Sandy Shore Motel respectively.
Select
Map
15.2 mi from Fishers Island15.2 mi from City Center
The Budget Inn is placed in a popular area of North Stonington, about 10 minutes' stroll from Trinity Lutheran Church and 1.8 miles from Pelloni Farm.
FromUS$ 182 /nightSelect
Super 8 Groton
Hotel
Map
7.8 mi from Fishers Island7.8 mi from City Center
Connecticut College Arboretum is about 10 minutes' drive from the 2-star Super 8, while The Submarine Force Museum is around 25 minutes' walk away.
FromUS$ 138 /nightSelect
7.4
Very good2 reviews
Map
7.7 mi from Fishers Island7.7 mi from City Center
Lyman Allyn Art Museum is 1.5 miles away and New London Waterfront Park can be reached within 5 minutes by car.
Select
8.0
Great12 reviews
Map
5.1 mi from Fishers Island5.1 mi from City Center
Located in the historic part of Mystic, the prestigious Harbor View Landing is 15 minutes' drive from Stonington's Old Lighthouse Museum.
FromUS$ 510 /nightSelect
Map
9.8 mi from Fishers Island9.8 mi from City Center
Located next to Mrs. Potato Head Statue, the venue comprises 26 rooms with sea views.
FromUS$ 245 /nightSelect

Where to stay in Fishers Island?

Best cheap hotels in Fishers Island

If you're looking for a place to stay on a budget, consider 3 Bedroom Emerald Island Sleeps 6, an affordable apartment at 189US$ per night. Enjoy your stay at American Sunshine West Stonebridge in Fishers Island city center if you're on a modest budget. A popular budget hotel choice in Fishers Island right near Splendid China is Ocean Florida Villas.

Luxury and boutique accommodation in Fishers Island

You can also spend your holidays at deluxe accommodation, such as American Sunshine Highlands Reserve situated near Disney's BoardWalk, while you're vacationing in Fishers Island.

Explore and find your best apartments, B&Bs and others

If you're looking for a homey place to stay, consider 3 Bedroom Townhome With West Facing Splash Pool B&B apartment, situated beside Walt Disney. If you're traveling to Fishers Island on business, staying near Disney's Hollywood Studios at American Sunshine Disney Area Executive may be a good option. If you are looking for a comfy resort hotel in Fishers Island, consider Starmark Vacation Homes, Villas And Condos, which is also within 5 minutes' walking distance of Publix Super Market at Orange Lake Town Center.

Show moreLess

Fishers Island hotels essential information

🏨 Hotels in Fishers Island 45
👛 Lowest price 45 USD
✍️ Hotels Reviews 3 880